Workforce experts say recent media reports about high demand for philosophers to train AI programs in ethics are likely more hype than reality.
“This is both a real trend and also overhyped,” said Derek Leben, an associate teaching professor of business ethics at Carnegie Mellon University.
He noted recent estimates that philosophy-related jobs account for about 5% of AI positions, while AI-related jobs comprise 26% of philosophy jobs.
“These are still mostly jobs in universities rather than tech companies, though,” Mr. Leben added.
Other analysts stressed that the hiring affects only a small number of academic philosophers and finance/legal experts with some philosophical background.
“As per our data, the demand for the jobs where humans would supervise model thinking progressed from near 0 to a separate job line, but mostly within finance and legal areas,” said Lacey Kaelani, CEO of Metaintro, a New York City-based job search engine.
“Graduates with philosophy backgrounds can easily fill this demand due to the nature of the task requiring systematic ethical thinking, rather than a philosophy degree itself,” Ms. Kaelani said.
The New York Times reported this month that AI companies such as Anthropic and Google DeepMind are paying professional philosophers $250,000 to $400,000 a year to translate traditional moral systems into “constitutional rules” for artificial intelligence users and chatbots to discuss ethical dilemmas.
That’s significantly higher than the median salary of $65,000 among the nation’s 543,810 workers with a philosophy and religion degree, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data.
Similar articles have appeared in Business Insider, The Times of India and the trade publication New Scientist.
Academics warned that these reports could create false expectations of a broad hiring boom for the 7,000 to 8,000 people who earn bachelor’s degrees in philosophy annually from U.S. colleges.
“It is remarkable that some AI organizations are directly seeking [people with] high-level philosophical expertise,” said Fabrizio Cariani, chairman of the University of Maryland’s philosophy department. “However, there is much less evidence that they have created a sizable entry-level career track for philosophy graduates generally.”
The University of Maryland is launching a bachelor of arts degree in human-centered AI this fall.
Mr. Cariani said there is no accurate count of AI job listings for philosophy graduates. He said AI-related hiring in his field has been limited to a handful of “accomplished professional philosophers, usually with PhDs and substantial research experience.”
Analysts say philosophers who specialize in ethics, logic, language, mind, epistemology, decision theory and political philosophy have the best shots at such jobs.
Fad or pipeline
Workforce analysts confirmed that AI companies have recruited professional ethicists, lawyers and finance experts rather than recent bachelor’s degree graduates.
“The window where ’philosophy major’ alone commands a premium is narrow,” said Patrice Williams-Lindo, CEO of Career Nomad, an Atlanta-based AI workforce intelligence company. “What holds value is the reasoning, priced into a role the market can’t yet automate.”
Ms. Williams-Lindo noted that the new jobs involve writing guidelines, ranking model outputs against them and structuring AI responses to be ethically consistent — and stressed that such contract work to train bots is already “being commoditized and offshored” to save money.
Recent headlines suggest the work of teaching AI to behave itself can’t progress fast enough.
Last year, the Federal Trade Commission launched an investigation into the negative impact of AI companions on children and teens who form intense emotional “relationships” with them.
FTC Commissioner Mark Meador cited the example of Adam Raine, a 16-year-old boy who hanged himself in April 2025 after ChatGPT said he didn’t “owe anyone” his survival and advised him on the best kind of “load-bearing” noose to use.
A study in JAMA Psychiatry in March found that all versions of the generative artificial intelligence chatbot ChatGPT exhibited high rates of inappropriate responses to questions testing for delusions, hallucinations and paranoid thoughts.
A team of psychiatrists found that the free version of ChatGPT was the most likely to affirm unstable thinking, which they called problematic for “economically disadvantaged” users with greater risks of becoming psychotic.
Mr. Cariani, the University of Maryland philosophy chair, insisted that philosophers are well-suited to correct such flaws.
“Philosophy graduates do well because the discipline trains them to think rigorously, write clearly, and argue well,” he said. “It is encouraging that some firms recognize the relevance of philosophical research to those problems.”
Teaching AI
Philosophers working with AI say the goal is to create ethical safeguards — such as kindness, empathy and respect for human life — that make conversational chatbots more trustworthy in real-world interactions.
“Without ethical training, AI is likely to hurt the most vulnerable, increase inequality, and thereby fuel social tensions, especially when AI is applied in criminal justice, medicine, education, and business,” said Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, a Duke University professor of practical ethics who teaches AI bots ethical ways of discussing military drones and the allocation of scarce medical resources.
Mr. Sinnott-Armstrong co-designed Banjo, an AI-powered conflict-resolution platform that helps professors and students hold civil arguments about hot-button moral topics.
Several universities are piloting Banjo, and more than 40 others are in discussions to do the same.
“We still won’t always agree, but AI can help us determine when we do,” he said, referring to the moral questions people pose to bots.
Some professional academics have become “resident philosophers” or “model-behavior researchers” at leading AI labs in recent months.
Additional job listings seek philosophers for roles such as “alignment researcher,” “responsible-AI researcher,” “AI ethicist” and “AI policy manager.”
“This will not hold universal relevance for all philosophy degrees, but those associated with ethics, politics and logic will likely find their capabilities more in demand than a few years ago,” said Marcus Mossberger, chief market strategy officer at the workforce analytics company LYTIQS.
Other companies say they are looking for lawyers, engineers and financial analysts with some ethical awareness, but not necessarily a degree.
Jimmy Carter, co-founder & CEO of Daemo AI, said his San Francisco software startup now screens for “applied philosophy” skills in all job applicants — including openings for engineer roles that have nothing to do with ethics.
“When we design an AI agent that briefs a lobbyist every morning, someone has to decide what ’important’ means for that person, how to represent conflicting sources fairly, and when the system should admit it doesn’t know,” Mr. Carter said.
“Candidates trained to interrogate concepts and spot hidden assumptions do this way better than candidates who only learned to code,” he added.
Bin Song, a philosophy professor at private Washington College in Maryland, noted that undergraduate majors in his discipline have traditionally performed better on law school and graduate admissions exams than other undergraduates.
He said that better prepares them to work with AI as future lawyers and financial analysts – as long as they master leading moral traditions such as Aristotelian virtue ethics, Kantian deontology, consequentialism, Christian ethics, Buddhist ethics and Confucian ethics.
“Philosophers serve as ethical gatekeepers, helping determine what kinds of information, values, and reasoning should shape AI systems,” Mr. Song said.
Contact the author
Please read our comment policy before commenting.