- Sunday, November 22, 2026

Thanksgiving was our first national holiday, celebrated before we were even a nation. It lies at the heart of our national identity, which is why the left hates it so much.

In 2019, The New York Times ran an unthink piece titled “The Horrible History of Thanksgiving.” Do a Google search and see how many articles are anti-Thanksgiving (lots) versus those that are pro-Pilgrim — damn few.

Thanksgiving is said to celebrate White supremacy, slavery, colonialism, war and oppression. According to liberal sachems, that is the sum total of American history, an evil that started at Plymouth Rock.

People were interested in these podcasts

In reality, the Pilgrims who landed on the stormy coast of New England in 1620 planted the seeds of religious liberty, self-government and capitalism on these shores. Initially, they held property communally. When they got tired of starving, they switched to private plots.

Strict Christians, the Pilgrims left Britain to escape the tyranny of the Church of England. The Mayflower Compact was the beginning of popular sovereignty on these shores.

Their Thanksgiving celebration has its roots in Deuteronomy, where the Children of Israel are commanded to give an “offering of thanksgiving” from their first fruits “when you come into the land which the Lord has given you.”

The Pilgrims thought of themselves as counterparts of the Israelites. Britain was their Egypt and the New World the promised land.

The holiday’s religious roots are another reason the left loathes it. Vladimir Lenin said, “Socialism necessarily involves the propaganda of atheism.” Statism says: Thou shalt have no gods before me.

The Pilgrims sacrificed for their God.

They endured a 66-day trans-Atlantic voyage in a 94-foot vessel at one of the worst times of the year. The Mayflower’s 102 passengers were confined below deck for weeks at a time with bad water and sparse rations.

During their first winter in New England, roughly half their number died of diseases including pneumonia, tuberculosis and dysentery. Their modern critics complain about being stuck in traffic for an hour and whine piteously when their DoorDash meal arrives late.

The left calls the Pilgrims and the other Europeans who followed in their wake invaders. Yet those who stream across our border today, bent on exploitation and conquest, are hailed as well-meaning newcomers.

The case against the Pilgrims is a pack of lies.

They had no slaves. Most of the American Indian tribes did, usually taking captives in war. Slavery was a universal institution that existed throughout history. In ancient Rome, slaves made up 30% to 40% of the population.

Our relations with American Indians were often unfortunate, but they were the same all over the world when people with superior firepower encountered less-advanced cultures. Still, Cochise and Geronimo did not do badly.

Russia colonized the Eurasian Steppe. China did the same in Central Asia. The Aztecs and Incas had empires of their own, which they ruled brutally. Yet we are the only ones asked to do perpetual penance.

The essence of Thanksgiving is gratitude. The left is about resentment, including rage against parents, society, and the wealthy and successful.

Those not afflicted by the liberal mind virus understand there is much for which we should be thankful, beginning with the fact that we live in the freest, most prosperous nation on earth.

From the Plymouth Colony, America spread across the continent.

We became a cornucopia from which blessings spilled to cover the earth — including crops, inventions and medical advances. In the 20th century, we saved humanity from the twin horrors of fascism and communism and are now a bulwark against totalitarianism and Islamism.

We pioneered representative government and human rights. We became a nation of town meetings, courts and legislatures.

In “Democracy in America,” Alexis de Tocqueville, that astute observer of our infant republic, said the greatness of America could be found in its churches.

That also started with the Pilgrims and others of faith who braved the wilderness to build a civilization, including a place for the word of God.

In my grade school classroom, in a more innocent time, there hung a picture of a Pilgrim family making their way to church. The father carries a Bible and a blunderbuss. Faith and freedom are inseparable, then as now.

More than a people, the Pilgrims were an idea — one of liberty, prosperity and piety — that took root in the fertile soil of this blessed land. To reject Thanksgiving is to reject America. Put that in your woke peace pipe and smoke it.

• Don Feder is a columnist with The Washington Times.

Follow the author

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.