A federal appeals court has ruled that the designated voter program then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi created during the pandemic to let lawmakers vote remotely on bills was unconstitutional.
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the Constitution requires there to be a quorum of lawmakers present before business can be conducted — and that means being in the Capitol.
“‘Proxy presence’ does not count,” Judge Cory T. Wilson wrote for the court’s majority. “While the chambers of the legislature have much discretion regarding their rules of procedure, the Quorum Clause’s constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat.”
People were interested in these podcasts
The proxy voting was Ms. Pelosi’s way of keeping the House operating while letting her members carry out the social distancing preached by government health professionals during the first years of the pandemic.
Lawmakers who didn’t want to come to the chamber to cast votes could designate a fellow member to cast a vote for them. They were supposed to attest that they couldn’t be present because of the health emergency.
The practice ended up being abused.
Some members used the scheme to cast hundreds of votes without setting foot in the chamber.
Democrats used proxy voting to cast votes while attending a space launch in Florida.
Republicans, initially reluctant, eventually joined the fracas, using proxy voting while they attended a conservative convention.
The Senate never adopted the practice and continued to have members show up in person to do business.
Overall, Democrats were more frequent users of the program, which helped Ms. Pelosi pass bills that might otherwise have failed if lawmakers had been required to show up.
One of those was the large fiscal 2023 spending bill, which passed just days before Christmas in 2022.
The final vote tally was 225-201. Of those, 226 members voted by proxy — meaning more than half the chamber wasn’t officially present.
Texas sued to block a portion of that bill, raising the issue that a quorum wasn’t present.
The case has bounced through the court for years, ending in Friday’s decision by the full 5th Circuit. The court split 9-8.
The dissenters said the court should have deferred to Congress, saying the Constitution lets the chambers set their own rules for operations.
Judge James E. Graves Jr., writing for the dissenters, said the Constitution’s Quorum Clause doesn’t include the word “physical presence.”
He called the majority’s decision “illogical, inexplicable and invalid.”
“In light of the plain language of the Clause, its basic purpose, and the historical practice of Congress since its inception, I would conclude that the Quorum Clause does not require physical presence for a house of Congress to conduct business,” he wrote.
But Judge Wilson said history worked against proxy voting. He said that for more than two centuries nobody thought a quorum included people not present. And that’s not because there wasn’t an incentive. Large absences were common in the early Congresses.
Proxy voting ended after Republicans took control of the chamber following the 2022 election.
Some lawmakers have suggested bringing it back to ease the travel burden on members.
Judge Wilson said Friday’s ruling was limited. It didn’t overturn the entire 2023 spending bill, but instead lets Texas be carved out of enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which was tucked inside the measure.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.