Saturday, November 21, 2026

Congress gets dismal approval ratings, but how much does it actually get done? 

On this episode of “On Cue,” host Mary McCue Bell puts that question to Craig Volden of the Center for Effective Lawmaking, whose team scores every member on lawmaking alone.

They get into why Jim Jordan’s score landed far below his predicted benchmark, how show horses compare with workhorses, what Democrats’ promised subpoenas could mean for the next session and which traits point to effective freshmen. 

People were interested in these podcasts

[BELL] The 2026 midterms have reshaped Congress, bringing new faces to Washington and shifting the balance of power. However, winning an election is one thing. Actually getting things done in Congress is another. 

So, what makes a good lawmaker? Is it experience, political influence, or the ability to work across party lines? As it turns out, there’s a way to measure that.

I’m Mary McCue Bell, and today on On Cue, we’re joined by Craig Volden, co-director of the Center for Effective Lawmaking, to explore the science, data and research behind what makes an effective member of Congress and what that could tell us about the lawmakers Americans just elected. 

What I want to get into first is how your organization is able to define what is effective and what separates an effective member of Congress versus an ineffective one.

[VOLDEN] We are the Center for Effective Lawmaking, which means we incorporate lawmaking, but we do set aside some things. So an effective member of Congress might be doing some great oversight or constituency services and so on. But we’re in the lawmaking space. And so we actually score every member of Congress for what they get done in that space.

To do so, we look at: How many bills do they introduce? How far do those bills move through the lawmaking process? So we give them a bit of credit if they get some action in committee, like a hearing or a markup, subcommittee vote. They get a little more credit if their bill makes it to the floor of their home chamber, the House or the Senate. A little more credit if they pass their home chamber and still more credit if they become law.

But we also know that not every bill is the same. And so in our metrics, we upgrade the biggest issues of the day. So if they’re tackling a major financial services reform or immigration policy that gets a lot of media coverage, they get upgraded. And if they’re just working on commemorative things, naming post offices and the like, we kind of downgrade that as less important.

We also know that in Congress today, more lawmaking is done through those bills being embedded in larger packages than as the bills becoming law by themselves. And so what we do is we take the text of every bill and compare it to the text of every law. And if their bill is embedded in that law, we give them credit for that as well.

And so it’s a multi-stage process, but it’s more or less how do you contribute relative to everybody else to the lawmaking process? We combine that all into a single score. We give it an average of one. And so we’re able to see who’s really low compared to others and who’s really high compared to others. We do that overall. We do that for 20 different issue areas. And we make all those data available up on our website, thelawmakers.org, so anybody can take a look.

[BELL] How would that apply for quiet versus loud members of Congress? The one I’m thinking of is Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri. He and his team are good about getting clicks on social media for big moments and hearings, whether it’s an investigation and he’s grilling someone or something along the lines of that. But he also is able to work across the aisle. So when it comes to someone who’s loud like him versus someone who works behind the scenes, does that change how you would measure their effectiveness? Or is that another factor that goes into it?

[VOLDEN] It’s not embedded into our metrics, but it is something that we’re able to explore. So classically, there’s this distinction between show horses and work horses in Congress. And we can imagine and kind of illustrate those folks who aren’t all that interested in lawmaking, are interested in either getting on TV or a big social media following or gotcha moments at hearings. They’re not built into our metric. And so our metric would find more of the legislative workhorses, the committee chairs, those who are really interested in a policy area and making sure they’re building up those coalitions to get things done.

Now, relative to that dichotomy, show horse versus workhorse, there are some people who do both really well, as well as constituent services and many other things. And so it’s not, if we hear of somebody, they must be a terrible lawmaker. Not at all. But there are also people who kind of underperform on all of those elements.

Watch the video for the full conversation.

See more from Mary McCue Bell

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Please read our comment policy before commenting.