- Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Losing an election is never fun. Getting swamped by an electoral wave is even worse. Despite that, the Republicans had a good night on Nov. 3 for two very specific reasons.

First, the voters sent the Republicans a timely and urgent warning about the path they are traveling and its likely terminal point. Eventually, the party will need to move beyond President Trump.

Many in the Republican ecosystem have been concerned about what the 2028 presidential election will look like — more specifically, whether the next cycle will be another referendum on Mr. Trump.

People were interested in these podcasts

Detaching emotionally from the current administration and turning attention to what will come next could have been a six- or seven-year process spread across three election cycles. A muddied set of electoral results could have made it much more challenging for the party and its elected officials to think and speak clearly about the 2028 election cycle.

The voters solved that problem by issuing a dispositive and incontestable verdict in this cycle. It is now impossible to argue that the president needs undue deference on the selection of Republican nominees in 2028.

Second, many people have spent considerable time and effort trying to explain what happened in the elections. It is not complicated: A greater number and percentage of Democrats turned out than did Republicans.

In the end, voters nationally tilted toward Democratic candidates by about 14 percentage points. Republicans slid backward with respect to Black, Hispanic and young voters.

The real question is why it all happened. Let me offer a theory that has not been discussed, at least not openly or to a sufficient degree: American conservatism has suffered an intellectual collapse.

Under the weight of the president’s popularity, conservatives have simply given way in all kinds of circumstances. In all elements of governance — spending, wartime powers, socialization of costs and privatization of benefits, restraint in personal and professional lives — the political right, conservatives or whatever you want to call them, has simply stopped arguing or presenting alternatives.

The uncomfortable truth is that those on the political right have been mostly happy to ride along in the president’s wake and not ask too many questions about the policies being promoted or actions being taken. One small example should suffice. The federal government now has an equity stake in 42 theoretically private-sector companies. That feels a lot like socialism.

Maybe another example is in order. I am old enough to remember when Republicans at least pretended to care about the size of the federal government and fiscal discipline. In the fiscal year immediately preceding the election, the federal budget was about $7.4 trillion, and the deficit was $1.992 trillion. The year before, federal spending was $7 trillion and the deficit was $1.775 trillion. I could go on, but you get the point.

In the absence of understood, meaningful and forcefully defended policies from the right, the electorate slid toward the side making actual arguments, however deficient those arguments were.

Those on the right have been given a gift. The voters, as they sometimes do, have shuffled the deck — and in so doing have created an opportunity for conservatives to take a step back, reset themselves and begin once again to fully participate in the national debate. They need to embrace the moment.

• Michael McKenna is a contributing editor at The Washington Times.

Follow the author

Copyright © 2026 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

Story Topics

Please read our comment policy before commenting.