The Trump administration’s handling of the war with Iran has polarized some analysts in Washington who have furiously argued for months that the costly conflict has permanently undermined America’s position in one of the world’s most vital regions.
Washington critics of the war with Iran are sounding an ominous new alarm in recent weeks, warning that the conflict will cost the U.S. its longstanding position of primacy in the region.
But a Middle East minus American money, muscle and leadership is an idea with little or no connection to geopolitical reality, say leaders and insiders across the Middle East.
People were interested in these podcasts
“I think we need more of America rather than less America,” Abdulkhaleq Abdulla, a retired United Arab Emirates political scientist, said in remarks at a recent security forum at the Hili Forum in Abu Dhabi.
“The only global security guarantor is there,” he told attendees. “It’s America.”
Mohamed Qubaty, a former Yemeni minister and ambassador based in Aden, told The Washington Times in a recent interview that the U.S. remains a valuable ally for the region, despite lingering questions about the Trump administration’s comprehensive strategy.
“Washington remains indispensable, particularly for intelligence, early warning and integrated air and missile defense,” Mr. Qubaty said. “The question is whether American support will be sustained and connected to a wider strategy, or remain limited to helping Saudi Arabia absorb attacks. That distinction matters … partners judge leadership by whether it helps build security that lasts, not only by whether it helps intercept the next missile.”
But the tense situation in the region has some in the Gulf relying more than ever on Washington.
Mohammed Al Dhaheri, deputy director general of the Anwar Gargash Diplomatic Academy in Abu Dhabi, said the war has made the United Arab Emirates’ relationship with the U.S. “certainly closer,” telling The Times that a war shows “which relationships are real.”
Frustration with U.S.
U.S. President Trump, who launched the war in February promising to topple Iran’s regime, has repeatedly argued that his strategy of irregular strikes and continuous economic pressure is working and making the world safer.
He argued again for maintaining the status quo of blockade and strikes this week while attending a summit of Asian leaders in the Philippines.
He told reporters that the U.S. pressure is working but that the Pentagon remains “locked and loaded” in case of provocation.
But the president’s critics in Washington foreign-policy circles, including some in his own party, are increasingly frustrated with the cost, conduct and duration of the war. The under-reported damage to American military bases and equipment and the ongoing strain on carefully balanced diplomatic relationships will, in the end, cost the U.S. dearly.
Doubtful analysts assert the ongoing conflict merely exposed structural flaws in Washington’s regional standing, pointing to years of containment strategy against rogue states such as Iraq and Iran that had already left American influence precariously frayed.
That strategy has not forced those regimes to collapse or reform, but in many cases has entrenched them and imposed a dangerous economic burden on millions of people.
Iran’s wide-reaching response to U.S. and Israeli strikes has also weakened the perception that the U.S. military can universally protect its allies.
That gloomy assessment, summarized in an oft-cited October think-piece, “The End of the American Middle East,” by George Washington University political scientist Marc Lynch, has found eager adherents in Washington.
But an epitaph for “the American Middle East” is viewed more skeptically in Gulf capitals.
Israeli businessman Eli Bar-On, the CEO of MENA2050, a Jerusalem-based regional development organization, is much more optimistic about the post-war prospects for the U.S. — and for his own country.
“I do think that we have a golden opportunity now, and I think the last two years of the Trump administration is the window. The time window in which we, the U.S., could act decisively and fast. We’ve had these two competing narratives or efforts in the region over the years, one of fragmentation, radicalization, resistance and one of more regional cooperation and integration,” Mr. Bar-On said.
No viable alternative
Middle East analysts agree that the war has exposed the limits of America’s security guarantees — but the conflict has also cast in sharp relief the reality that, for now, no one else can do the job.
Qatari Foreign Ministry spokesman Majed Al Ansari said last month that the U.S.-Qatari security relationship is “very important, but is not enough.” He added that Gulf states need “self-sufficiency” in security.
“I think the United States is in a strong position after the war,” Amer Al Sabaileh, a Jordanian security analyst, told The Times. “Without the U.S., I think it might have looked worse,” he added.
Anwar Gargash, a senior diplomatic adviser to the UAE president, said in remarks at a security conference in Abu Dhabi earlier this month that the region should “prepare for a long period of uncertainty in which neither a decisive resolution nor a stable regional order can be taken for granted.”
That reality is fueling a regional race to build defense arrangements outside the American umbrella.
Saudi Arabia expanded its Mecca Defense Pact with Pakistan this year to include Turkey, and all signatories vowed to defend one another if attacked.
The Houthi attacks on Saudi infrastructure and military facilities are testing the pact. Pakistan and Turkey have agreed to send military assets to the kingdom, and Syria is reportedly considering similar help.
“U.S. allies, well, in this case, particularly the Saudis, were disappointed from the U.S. response to the attacks on them,” Mr. Bar-On said, adding that Washington needs to reassure allies in the region that the U.S. isn’t pulling back.
“If we look into the future of where it’s all going, I think the U.S. should make very clear to all its allies that it’s there,” he said.
Mr. Qubaty, the former Yemeni minister, said the answer is “not simply to choose between Washington, new defense partners, or a deal with the Houthis. Each can serve a different purpose; none can substitute for a Yemeni political and security settlement.”
Reassuring businesses
The carefully constructed image of a business safe haven that the Gulf had crafted over the past decade was also shattered by the Iran war as drones and missiles crashed into civilian buildings and commercial infrastructure.
But leaders in the Gulf have worked hard over the past year to assure Western investors that the U.S.-Gulf partnership is not going anywhere.
Yousef Al Otaiba, the Emirates’ ambassador to the U.S., wrote in an Oct. 19 letter to the U.S.-UAE Business Council that business is moving forward as usual, despite the occasional flare-up in the Iran war.
“We adapt, we persevere — and more than ever, we do it in close partnership with the US. Our commitments to the United States remain firm, our major investments are moving forward and expanded access to advanced technology is opening further opportunities,” he wrote. “We have faced many obstacles and challenges, but they have only made us closer, stronger and more determined than ever before.”

Please read our comment policy before commenting.