- The Washington Times
Wednesday, December 22, 2010

In the annual battle over “Merry Christmas” and “Happy holidays,” specificity wins out again.

A survey released this week by the Marist Poll showed that 61 percent of Americans preferred the “Merry Christmas” greeting, against just 35 percent who thought “Happy holidays” is more appropriate. The remainder said they were unsure.

“When it comes to holiday greetings, about six in 10 Americans want to throw political correctness out the window,” the Marist pollsters wrote.

The preference for “Merry Christmas” was consistent across nearly every demographic group — both sexes, all income and education levels, every region of the country — with percentages in the high 50s or low 60s.

However, there was one significant dissenting group: youths. Americans ages 18 to 29 preferred “Happy holidays” by a margin of 55 percent to 39 percent, while every age group 30 and older favored “Merry Christmas” by margins of almost 2-to-1 or more.

Rob Schwarzwalder, senior vice president at the Family Research Council, agreed that one cause of such a gap likely is American society’s increasingly irreligious culture.

“The influence of a secular culture that is often hostile to Christian faith unquestionably has had an effect on younger people,” he said, though he went on to elaborate that “there is much good news about today’s young believers, who polls show to be more pro-life than previous generations and whose concern for those in need mirrors Christ’s compassion for the downtrodden … as we communicate truth in a winsome, clear and persuasive manner, many of our youth are listening with open minds and hearts.”

The Marist Poll surveyed 1,029 adults from Dec. 2-8 and has an error margin of 3 percentage points for the overall findings and higher numbers for subgroups.

The findings mirror similar surveys, even when the question was specifically phrased in terms of how businesses should greet their customers.

Rasmussen Reports found in a telephone survey of 1,000 adults taken Nov. 20-21 that 72 percent of adults “prefer stores to show signs saying Merry Christmas [instead of] Happy holidays,” while just 22 percent prefer the latter option.

A survey released last week by the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) found similar results, though by a much smaller margin. The survey of 1,105 Americans taken Dec. 9-12 asked whether “stores and businesses should greet their customers with ‘Happy Holidays’ or ‘Seasons Greetings’ instead of ‘Merry Christmas’ out of respect for people of different faiths, or not.”

Just 44 percent preferred the generic references, while 49 percent said stores should say “Merry Christmas” and 7 percent did not know.

The “war on Christmas” — stories involving taking either “Christ” out of “Christmas” or “Christmas” out of the “holidays” — have become a staple of November and December news coverage in recent years. Examples this year include:

• The American Family Association made out a list this month, after checking it twice, of retailers who use terms like “holidays” over terms like “Christmas.” “AFA has reviewed the website and newspaper ads of Radio Shack, Office Depot and Staples. We found terms like ‘holiday deals,’ ‘holiday prices,’ ‘gifts’ and ‘happy holidays,’ but no ‘Christmas,’ ” the conservative family-values group wrote.

• Chase Bank corporate headquarters ordered a Southlake, Texas, branch to remove a donated 9-foot Christmas tree for fear of causing offense.

The company wants to ensure that decorations include only what “everyone is comfortable with, regardless of how they celebrate the season,” JPMorgan Chase spokesman Greg Hassell told the Fort Worth (Texas) Star-Telegram.

• Also this month, the Federal Reserve told Payne County Bank, as part of its quadrennial inspection, that the Oklahoma bank could not display religious signs and symbols that included a daily Bible verse, buttons with the phrase “Merry Christmas, God With Us,” and crosses on public counters.

They said the “discouragement clause” in bank regulations meant that these symbols indicated offense and discrimination to Muslims, Jews or others. After a public outcry, the Fed regulators backed down and allowed the Christmas decorations to stay until the legal matters can be clarified.

Unlike the Marist survey, the PRRI and Rasmussen polls asked questions about political and religious affiliation and found sharp divides.

“Ninety-one percent of Republicans … like store signs that wish them a ‘Merry Christmas,’ compared to just 58 percent of Democrats,” Rasmussen wrote.

The PRRI survey found that while 43 percent of Americans had a family tradition involving the Gospels’ accounts of Jesus’ birth, nearly as many (40 percent) read the Clement Clarke Moore poem “A Visit from St. Nicholas” (better known by its first line, “Twas the Night before Christmas”).

“Celebrations of the birth of Jesus in Christianity have always blended the explicitly religious with elements of the contemporary culture,” said Robert P. Jones, PRRI’s chief executive. “That roughly equal numbers of Americans both read the story of the birth of Jesus from the Bible and the story of Santa Claus in ‘Twas the Night before Christmas is a continuation of that tradition.”

The coexistence of religion-specific and generic greetings was on display Wednesday at President Obama’s news conference.

Jake Tapper of ABC News and Mike Emanuel of Fox News greeted Mr. Obama with a “Merry Christmas,” which the president reciprocated. When Mr. Obama turned to Dan Lothian and the CNN reporter wished him “Happy holidays,” the president repeated those words back. Later, Juan Carlos Lopez of CNN en Espanol prefaced his question with “Feliz Navidad,” and Mr. Obama said the same words, Spanish for “Happy Christmas.”

When it came time to end the conference with a parting greeting of his own, what did Mr. Obama say?

“So with that, everybody, I want to wish you all a merry Christmas, happy holidays, happy new year.”

And in the final words as he walked out, Mr. Obama got in one more language, Hawaiian, in telling the press, “Mele kalikimaka.”

• Victor Morton can be reached at vmorton@washingtontimes.com.

Copyright © 2022 The Washington Times, LLC.