Perhaps one of the most shocking witnesses at the child-molestation trial of Jerry Sandusky was his wife of 46 years, Dorothy, known as Dottie.
Mrs. Sandusky paid her husband’s bail, steadfastly declared his innocence and testified on the stand that she never saw or heard anything strange or suspicious during the years when her husband brought boys over for dinner and sleepovers in the basement.
Asked whether she could think of a reason why eight men would come forward to accuse her husband of molesting and raping them, Mrs. Sandusky’s answer was: “I have no idea. … I don’t know what it would be for.”
But the Sandusky household was divided in its members’ views of its patriarch. Adopted son Matt Sandusky said last week, before the former Penn State assistant football coach was convicted of nearly all charges associated with the molestation of 10 boys, that Sandusky also had sexually abused him.
How is it possible for a wife to live with a child molester for years, have the abuse going on in the home, and not know what was going on?
The answers, analysts say, lie in the complexities of human relationships, the existence of heartless psychopaths in people’s lives and the natural desire to not see things that do not make sense or that threaten one’s own life.
“I never suspected a thing,” said Darlene Ellison, who said she did not learn that her ex-husband led a pedophile organization until he was arrested.
“I think there are three options in terms of Dottie Sandusky,” Jeff Dion, deputy executive director of the National Center for Victims of Crime, said in a recent interview.
“One, she didn’t know. Two, she didn’t want to know. Or three, she knew, but acknowledging it, or doing anything about it, would be so disruptive to her life that she chose not to,” he said.
It’s common for a spouse or family member to fall into the latter two categories, he said.
“They don’t go into rooms when they’re afraid of what might be going on. They don’t ask questions purposefully when they wonder about something because they don’t want to know,” Mr. Dion said. “Or they do know [something’s wrong], but they feel afraid that they can’t say anything” because the perpetrator has power and control over them; there’s an idea that “this is something you have to tolerate, this is part of the arrangement.”
Another scenario is that a spouse “just decides that anything I do will end badly for my family, for my kids, and so I’m just going to make a decision to ignore it.”
The victim said he went into the bathroom to take a shower, and Sandusky entered the bathroom and motioned to the boy to give him oral sex. But when Mrs. Sandusky asked, “Jerry, what are you doing in there?” the elder man leapt out of the room.
Indeed, he added, “she didn’t see anything” because “they were in the bathroom.”
Child sexual abuse is typically perpetrated by men, many of whom are married, and there are indeed women and mothers who are complicit and really know what’s going on, analysts say.
But it’s also common for their wives to be “in denial, to be blind, deaf and dumb, when it comes to these acts,” said Dr. Frank Ochberg, who teaches clinical psychiatry at Michigan State University and is a former associate director at the National Institute of Mental Health.
“Think about what it means to live your life with a man who’s living a lie and who has tremendous power and who has some perverted instincts and appetites,” Dr.Ochberg said.
It wasn’t all that long ago that women didn’t “dare speak back to your man,” he said. Also, some people’s personality types make them dependent, timid and trainable into a subordinate position.
Moreover, psychopaths know how to fool people, said Dr. Ochberg, who cautioned that he was not suggesting that Sandusky was a psychopath.
A psychopath has no conscience and therefore “has no capacity for feeling guilty,” remorse or concern for someone else’s pain, he said. They compensate by becoming very good at faking “normal” feelings and, in many cases, learn how to intimidate others either by force or through their personalities.
Pedophiles are “masters of deceit and deception,” said Ms. Ellison, a public speaker and author of “The Predator Next Door.”
Ms. Ellison can recall the horrible day in 2005 when she learned from FBI officials that her former husband, Phillip Todd Calvin, had been arrested in a sting operation on the North American Man-Boy Love Association (NAMBLA).
She was stunned to learn that her ex was no novice pedophile. He was a NAMBLA leader and was caught on his way with other men to engage in sex with boys. Her first thoughts were about the safety of their two children, their friends’ children and the children in the groups in which Calvin had volunteered.
Writing recently for the Daily Beast about Mrs. Sandusky, Ms. Ellison said it was possible for someone to “be married to a man for years, share a bed with him, raise children with him and still have no clue that he is a predator of young boys.”
Also, as a wife, even if suspicions arise, “your mind does not go there,” said “Jasmine Black,” who created healingwives.com a decade ago as a resource for women whose husbands or partners are sex offenders. Jasmine Black is an alias, the woman said, which allows her to share her story and still protect her privacy and that of her husband and their children.
If Mrs. Sandusky is like other wives, “she’s in a grieving process,” said Ms. Black. “Their life and their marriage as they knew it is over, and I’m sure she feels alone - you really find out who your friends are.
“That’s why we tell women, ‘Get counseling. Get through one day at a time.’ “